sorry guys...didn't mean to spark a huge rant/debate...just thought the video was cool...
sorry guys...didn't mean to spark a huge rant/debate...just thought the video was cool...
“What happens when an unstoppable force meets an immovable object?"
I think I missed something...anyway I thought the video was cool too. And I liked the Troopers attitude!
I have actually given this a lot of thought...
The two factors to consider are weapons and shields.
Star Wars:
Weapons - Laser cannons & proton torpedoes
Shields - Deflector screens
Star Trek:
Weapons - Phasers & photon/quantum torpedoes
Shields - a much more highly advanced type of shielding technology
What's interesting is that the deflector screens used by Star Wars ships are actually used by Star Trek ships as navigation shields, keeping asteroids and other particles from hitting the ship while it's in warp. They also completely block lasers. Meanwhile, phasers can completely pass through deflector shields, making the weapons and shields of Star Wars ships totally useless against Trek tech.
If the Enterprise had been at the Battle of Endor, it could have used its phasers and torpedoes to destroy the Death Star's firing ring, then literally flown through the entire Imperial fleet and decapitated each and every Star Destroyer.
This video is actually very accurate to what would actually happen (though Vader's use of the Force is greatly exaggerated, funny though it may be):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v4ijDlbvAxw
TCSS Red Squadron - The most kickawesome fighting force in the Galaxy.
Which Blue Luxeon is movie-accurate? Find out here.
Stardestroyer vs enterprise: Stardestroyer wins
Deathstar vs enterprise: Deathtar wins
suncrusher vs enterprise: Suncrusher wins
Leviathan Vs enterprise: Leviathan wins
Centerpoint station Vs enterprise: Centerpoin wins
shall i continue?
Definitely not; look at my above analysis.Originally Posted by DJMoonbass
Only if it can get a shot off, and we don't even know if lasers have any effect on ST shields whatsoever.
Doubtful. The Enterprise could beam the Sun Crusher's pilot into space. Also, the Sun Crusher doesn't cause those explosions on its own; it needs to detonate a nearby star and hope that it doesn't get caught in the blast itself. (and the Enterprise can warp out of the system faster than the 'Crusher's hyperdrive could even get ready to jump)
Definitely not.
The Enterprise could annihilate the station while easily avoiding its energy beam.
Hey, I love SW more than ST, but ST's weapons would completely destroy SW's.
TCSS Red Squadron - The most kickawesome fighting force in the Galaxy.
Which Blue Luxeon is movie-accurate? Find out here.
The force could drestroy the enterpirse, for example a Force Storm.
Last edited by Sairon; 05-15-2009 at 11:24 AM.
New to the forum: READ, READ, READ! it's the best way not to get flamed.
Time for a kirby dance <('-'<) (><) <('-')> (>'-')> (>'-'<)<('-'<) (><) <('-')> (>'-')> (>'-'<)
Quite possibly.
Though the most anyone ever actually did in the SW films was lift an X-wing. The SW EU kinda made the Jedi and Sith practically gods. (so would that mean that Trek could bring in the Q? heheheh...)
TCSS Red Squadron - The most kickawesome fighting force in the Galaxy.
Which Blue Luxeon is movie-accurate? Find out here.
If you're determined to cross genres here's some thoughts:
Imagine Vulcans as Jedi (robes, peace, no emotions, etc)
Now imagine an army of Klingons with red-bladed lightsabers.
Enjoy the mental image
I'm not anti-social, society is anti me
Saber-carying member of the FSM,
Barfly at the Intergalactic Kegger
That Jedi Spock has always been one of my favourite rabbittooth wallpapers along with Jedi Amidala and Dark Yoda
Erm........well, the video at the start of the thread was very entertaining and nicely done, anyway...
Last edited by Sethski; 05-15-2009 at 05:34 AM.
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
Bookmarks