I'm late for posting here, many aspects have been covered.
I'm however pointing a few things :
- I have a customer who told me he had troubles with wiring the recharge port with the kill switch using one of TCSS port. I remember corbin told me a long time ago that the current stock was not working as a kill switch. Just would like to make sure that there is no doubt now.
- while it does not really matter to have the kill switch topology for a resistor + luxeon setup, you NEED it as soon as you have an electronic device inside. Maybe not for a buck puck, if it resists to hight voltage but... a charger chops current and voltage for charging batteries. If you apply that to the board AND to the pack, the board might "start" and fool the current measurement of the charger which might... send even more and fry the board. NiMH are charged with current (with voltage monitoring), but voltage output by such a charger can go above 12V, which is the limit of CF.
In anycase, my "dumb engineer" point of view is WHY NOT putting a kill switch since it's very easy. If you answer "because my hilt is too small", then give us a favor : spend more money at TCSS and buy a new hilt (enginners have a really particular way of solving certain problems... ask me how much is 1+1, I'll ask you how much do you want it to be).
I haven't invented anything : this wiring / topology is WHAT IS USED in any electronic system that has an embeded recharge port (when the smart charger isn't internal). Same idea for cutting the speakers of your laptop when you insert your headphones in the side minijack female plug.
- the kill plug : neophyl was using little plastic parts he found here and there. I was machining some in PVC (takes ages). Not that I don't trust using a real recharge plug that you cut, but I prefer the safer way with something totally made of plastic. Casting is a solution as corbin said. On my side, I stopped proposing them cause I don't have the time to machine them, it takes me 15 minutes to make 2.
Bookmarks